A worked example: Coach Daniels and 22 players on a Tuesday night
Coach Daniels runs an under-14 soccer squad in Columbus, Ohio. Twenty-two players turn up for Tuesday practice, and he has 90 minutes: a warm-up, three drill stations, and a 30-minute scrimmage at the end. The old way was the captains' draft — two captains taking turns picking players while the rest stood in a line, the last few picks staring at the ground. It ate ten minutes and left the weakest players humiliated before a ball was kicked.
Now he does it from the sideline on his phone. He pastes the roster — 22 names, one per line — into the tool and chooses Number of teams mode with 2. One tap gives him two teams of 11: the Reds are Alvarez, Brooks, Chen, Davis, Evans, Foster, Grant, Hughes, Ingram, Jones, and Kim; the Blues are Lopez, Moore, Nguyen, O'Brien, Park, Quinn, Reed, Santos, Turner, Walsh, and Young. He reads them out, hands out bibs, and practice starts in two minutes instead of twelve.
For the drill stations he switches to Team size mode with 5 or 6 per group, which gives him four small-sided groups that rotate through passing, shooting, and defending stations every 12 minutes. Small groups mean more touches per player — in a 5-a-side drill, a player touches the ball roughly twice as often as in an 11-a-side game — and the random mix means the midfielders spend a station defending and the defenders spend a station attacking, which is exactly how versatile players are made.
When to use random teams in sport — and when not to
Random teams are ideal for practice and for fun: scrimmages, small-sided games, training stations, warm-up games, and in-squad tournaments where the point is development rather than winning. They stop the same clique dominating every session, they force players to adapt to new teammates, and they end the argument about who got the stronger side — "the generator picked it" is the fastest dispute resolution in youth sport.
They are the wrong choice when the teams must be balanced by position or ability. A real match team needs a goalkeeper, defenders, midfielders, and forwards in roughly the right proportions, and a random draw will not guarantee that. The fix is the same as in the classroom: randomize first, then adjust. Generate the teams, swap the goalkeeper, swap one strong attacker for another, and you have a fair match in under a minute — faster than any draft, and fairer than any captain's pick.
Random teams are also wrong for selection. If you are picking a representative squad for a league match, or deciding who makes the team and who does not, that is a coaching decision based on performance, attitude, and attendance — not a coin toss. Use random teams for everything up to the point of selection, and make selection deliberately, with reasons you can explain to a player and a parent. And for very small groups — five players turning up for a kickabout — do not reach for a tool at all; split 3-and-2 by hand and get on with the game.
Quick answers
How do you pick fair teams for a pick-up game?
List everyone who's playing and generate two even teams. If you know the skill levels, swap one or two players to balance the sides. It's faster than a playground draft — and because the starting point is random, nobody can complain about being picked last.
What is the best team size for practice drills?
For most field and court sports, 4v4 to 6v6 keeps everyone involved with plenty of touches. Use Team size mode to split a large squad into small-sided groups, then rotate the groups through stations.